Benign Interruptions in Students' Progress
Toward Graduation and Postgraduate Education
April 11, 1995
Eva T. H. Brann
Dean, St. John's College, Annapolis, Maryland
St. John's might do well to take the lead in speaking
out loudly against a current trend in education. It is the demand,
expressed in regulation and in reporting demands, that students
finish their education as quickly and uninterruptedly as possible.
While aimless dawdling wastes time and money, a well-controlled
stretching out of the college years and a delayed entry into graduate
or professional education has several short and long term advantages,
both pedagogical and practical. The rush to finish is one of a
number of ill-conceived current notions which this college should
oppose as articularly as possible, both for the sake of American
students and for its own reputation.
Delays in completing education may occur within the
undergraduate stretch or in entering upon postgraduate work. I
will begin by giving good reasons AGAINST such interruptions,
at St. John's and anywhere.
Undergraduate years:
- Dropping out is an undisciplined way for students
to manage their education.
- Too often the year away stretches into several
and then into drifting away altogether.
- Students may forget what they learned and have
difficulty in reentering a progressive curriculum such as ours.
- The time away from school is wasted in drifting
or in dead end jobs.
- Certain kinds of financial aid are lost.
Postgraduate schooling:
- There is no guarantee that once out of a school
environment, students will find their way back to advanced study.
- Graduate and professional schools may wonder
what the student was doing.
- Though our alumni are entitled to, and are explicitly
offered the help of the Placement Office, choosing and applying
to postgraduate school is (marginally) more difficult away from
college.
* * * * * *
The arguments FOR well-planned interruptions are,
however, far stronger than those against the practice.
Undergraduate:
- An intensely intellectual program like that at
St. John's (and at any college worth the tuition) wears out young
students, especially. They crave some worldly activity and the
relief of good hard ordinary work. When they come back they find
that the second stretch has more savor and zest.
- A year at the age of most of our undergraduates
is a long time, and returning students are often much more
mature. While the St. John's program, in appealing largely to
the intellect, is not designed for any particular age, it is a
great boon to the college and to the students themselves to be
somewhat more grown up, especially, in the upper years. They become
a stabilizing influence on the community.
- As it happens, the program, which is progressive
on the whole, has a distinct break after the sophomore year, so
that returning students tend to be able to pick up the new studies
even without much review. In most colleges, where many classes
are not done in sequence, interruption is not a problem in any
case.
- In that year away students begin to see how their
education prepares them for the working world, and they also begin
to understand what they need to learn that is not taught in this
or any school. Often they discover what they really want to do
(or can't bear doing) after they graduate, and they begin to make
the connection that will help them afterwards, perhaps even to
a first postgraduate job.
- In that year they can often make enough money
to relieve their accumulating college debt to some degree, or
even to save for the next stretch of schooling.
Postgraduate:
- Many thoughtful undergraduates are, rightly and
with our encouragement, so preoccupied with their studies that
their plans for the future have not jelled. They need some time
in the working world to focus on the postgraduate training they
really want.
- Conversely, the students who go right on, thinking
they know exactly what to study, are often deeply disappointed
and drawn to a wasteful and expensive career change. It seems
better to give the choice of profession time to mature.
- In applications to postgraduate schools the statement
of purpose plays an important role. It calls for focus and experience,
and becomes more persuasive as students gain perspective.
- In the present, very competitive, situation,
students with real-life experience and often with extra preparatory
courses (which can be taken while working) have a distinct edge.
Some professional schools in fact require such courses.
- Again, an interlude of earning money helps lighten
the financial burden.
* * * * * *
For all these reasons we should stop making students
feel that interruptions of this sort need an apology, and often
we should actively advise them to go slow.
This policy is, however, predicated on our finding
the means to help students spend their in between time profitably.
THE KIND OF HELP I AM THINKING OF CONSISTS OF A REGISTER
OF INTERNSHIPS AND APPRENTICESHIPS -- FIRMS, CORPORATIONS AND
AGENCIES WHERE OUR STUDENTS CAN DO REMUNERATED -- OR, IF THEY
CAN AFFORD IT, VOLUNTEER -- WORK WHILE LEARNING ABOUT A PROFESSION
THEY MIGHT WISH TO ENTER AND MAKING CONTACTS FOR THE FUTURE. Such
summer programs have often proved mutually satisfactory for students
and employers. We should try to collect year-long-opportunities
both for students and recent alumni, and help our students look
for them.
Miss Brann requests that responses be sent to her
via snail mail: Eva T. H. Brann, St. John's College, P.O. Box
2800, Annapolis, MD 21404.