Energy Long-Shots that could save the world

While we are rebuilding the entire American energy infrastructure, we must keep a watch for a true long-shot that could change the world. These are silver bullets that would win the sustainable future game and even the development process is immense fun just to follow.

By definition the long-shots are speculative and risky. No one has better than a one-in-a-thousand chance of succeeding. Still we must be like Edison who built 630 light bulbs before he got one that worked. When pressured to quit, he replied, "Never, I am the only one in the world who knows 600 ways not to make a light bulb.”

Most of the players in this high-tech knock-down-drag-out fight are small high-tech companies spun off from research labs. It is a high risk business and to get the resources they need they have to publicly and loudly make outrageous claims. Students need to be able to understand the strengths and weaknesses of such claims.

Right now there are a number of approaches that, if true, would result in all the power we need for a sustainable world. We cannot count on any one of them, yet we must keep the support flowing for them all. When we get a hit, the world will change.

Here are a few candidates for the energy silver bullet:

  1. Tokamak – This is the latest in a long line of big fusion reactors that would replace current nuclear power plants. Its development is about at the energy break even point. The work has been woefully underfunded, which has resulted in only slow progress. There is no reason to think that this approach will not eventually work, if adequately funded.
  2. Breeder Reactors – These replacements for current nuclear plants would make plutonium at the same time they produce energy. The technology has been proven to work. The breakdown that has stopped this idea cold is simply that it is too easy to make bombs from this materials produced in these reactors. This idea is dead for the foreseeable future.
  3. Power Space Stations -- These would be huge power generation stations in geosynchronous orbit that would beam energy back to Earth as microwaves. The idea has been around for a long time, but its many problems make this a very long-shot.
  4. Cold Fusion – This system claimed to catalyst hydrogen/hydrogen nuclear reaction at room temperature. This was a false start and is now dead.
  5. Table Top Fusion – This system using ultra sound to make cavitations bubbles in a fluid containing Deuterium. When the bubbles collapse they generate fantastic temperatures in their micro-domains. So far the early experiments have not been repeatable. This idea is barely hanging on.
  6. Helium-3 from the Moon -- This plan would harvest helium-3 from the lunar regolith and burn it in a Tokamak style reactor on Earth. The helium-3 would produce many orders of magnitude less radioactive wastes than fuels available on Earth. This idea requires two breakthroughs and is therefore a double long-shot.
  7. Focused Fusion Reactor – This system collapses an intense electric arc to generate the needed heat in nano-domains. It is fueled with common boron and hydrogen and feeds the reaction products through a standing wave tube directly generating electric energy. All the needed pieces of technology have been shown to work separately, but actually energy generation would require balancing them all as a system within a six dimensional space. This is still a promising contender in the fight and would also make a great interplanetary rocket.
  8. Bussard Polywell Fusion Reactor – This system uses six super-conducting rings to generate a magnetic field to confine the fusion reaction. It is small in size and under test by the Navy.

Education:

There are many lessons for students in this area. Starting with the idea that they should not despair, we could still win the big one.

A much more sophisticated lesson here involves being able to enthusiastically buy into a technological idea while still maintaining enough emotional separation that you can see its problems and so that you can move on when today's silver bullet turns out to be lead after all.

Status of Idea:

Several ideas have been built and tested but none have produced reproducible results. A way for students to follow th action and select their favorites is in order.

References:

Books: URL:

Rockler Banner 2

Contact Us:

Please, drop us an e-mail with your needs and ideas.

Thanks again for visiting our Web site.

  • Return to our student project ideas directory

    Woodware Designs, jriley@charm.net